What People Say

Elmton Testimonials

A Family Tradition Since 1945

THe Elmton reviews and testimonies
  • “How did I wait so long to try this gem?

    “How did I wait so long to try this gem?"


    Got a sausage pie and it was incredible. Medium crust that's sturdy but light. Cheese goes all the way to the edge, where it get burnt to a delicious crisp. 


    They include swiss in the blend, which gives it a little sharpness that I love.  Sauce is minimal and includes green peppers. Also tried a couple flavors (Louisiana & Hot BBQ) of wings which were excellent. I prefer them just a bit crispier, but they were all high quality, super tender meat and the sauces were great. This will be a regular stop from now on.

    Daniel K
  • The Elmton had the most unique pizza I have eaten!”

    “The Elmton had the most unique pizza I have eaten!”


    The cheese was amazing and the topping were very fresh!  The people there made everyone feel like you were at home.  I have visited maybe 12 different pizza places in the Youngstown area and this one ranks right up there!

    Craig Hockenberry
  • Delicious food and beverages,  authentic Italian cuisine!

    “Delicious food and beverages, authentic Italian cuisine!”

    Amazing sandwiches and the pizza is the best in town.  The Elmton is historic and family owned that you feel like you belong and will enjoy your feast with family and friends.  They have a wide variety of items on their menu,  famous boasted chicken,  salads, and  many other items,  but I always have to get the pizza.  You will not be disappointed.

    Dave Thomas
Daily Specials
BROASTED CHICKEN
REAL PIZZA
WEDNESDAY SPECIAL TUB OF CHICKEN
Share by: